David Lloyd wins Harrogate padel court appeal after neighbours compared the noise to gunshots
A government planning inspector has approved two padel courts at David Lloyd's Harrogate club, overturning a council refusal, after ruling that the noise evidence had not been challenged.

David Lloyd has won its long-running fight over two padel courts at its club in Harrogate. A government planning inspector has allowed the gym chain's appeal, overturning North Yorkshire Council's refusal, The Stray Ferret reports.
Built first, permission later
The courts sit on Oakdale Place, on the site of a former tennis court and social area. David Lloyd built them without planning permission. Nearby residents complained that the sound of the ball being hit was like gunshots and said it echoed around the Oak Beck valley.
A first retrospective application was refused. In October 2025 the council issued an enforcement notice ordering David Lloyd to stop using the courts altogether, and the club stopped playing on them. It then put in fresh plans in February, revised to include measures such as acoustic barriers.
Council officers recommended approval this time. Their case officer said the changes meant the courts would not cause "unacceptable harm", and the council's environmental health officer suggested limiting play to 8am to 8pm Monday to Saturday and 9am to 7pm on Sundays and public holidays. But at a meeting on 28 April, councillors on the Harrogate and Knaresborough area planning committee voted unanimously to refuse, citing the impact of noise on neighbours.
The chair of the Oak Beck Valley Residents Association had told councillors that residents would have to put up with "continuous noise" seven days a week, and that the proposed fencing would not stop it.
Why the inspector sided with David Lloyd
David Lloyd argued that the council had not explained why its committee went against its own officers, and had produced no evidence to dispute its noise assessment. The council said its decision was based on the combined noise of rackets hitting balls, balls rebounding off the glass and players socialising.
The inspector, DM Young, found that the council had not provided its own acoustic assessment reaching different conclusions. While acknowledging the concerns of councillors and residents, the inspector said they gave more weight to the technical evidence, which had not been rebutted, than to "assertions of harm, however genuinely held".
A familiar row, a different ending
Noise is the issue in almost every padel planning dispute we cover, from Sheffield, where a tennis club dropped its bid, to Glasgow, where councillors said yes despite 79 objections. Harrogate shows how appeals can play out: when an operator has a noise report and the council has nothing technical to set against it, an inspector may well back the evidence over the objections.
Elsewhere this week, Sunderland City Council approved a six-court centre at Rainton Bridge Business Park, with four courts under canopies and two outdoors, which is expected to create 17 jobs, the Northern Echo reports.
If you're new to the sport and wondering why it's louder than tennis, our explainer on what padel is covers the glass walls and solid rackets, and our guide to where to play padel in the UK helps you find a court near you.


